Deal of the Day
opinion
|
Are sports really more valuable than teachers? Published: February 10, 2010 By Roslyn Ryan After months of worry and speculation, it has come to this: some teachers in Powhatan, it was announced last week, may lose their jobs. There are worse things than losing one’s job, though it ranks pretty high on the list of life-altering blows. A job loss is unfortunate for anyone who has to face it. But when it happens to a teacher the impact extends beyond just the inconvenience to an individual or a family. Powhatan owes the noted quality of its school system to its teachers. The fact that we have come to a point where some may be sent packing is tragic. It was stated during a school board workshop last week that, at this point, athletic programs in the schools will not be on the chopping block despite the fact the school system will likely have to lay off teachers in order to balance this year’s budget. Naturally, no one wants to see school sports sacrificed. And part of the rational for funding them, according to school officials, is that athletic fields are akin to classrooms in that they offer valuable life lessons. Certainly, they do. They also offer students a chance to achieve their highest potential and, at the very least, something constructive to do with their time. It’s no secret that asking the schools to place athletics somewhere on the long list of things that need to be sacrificed would be tremendously unpopular. But just because the schools can’t fund athletics does not mean they all have to be cut. Asking parents to help subsidize sports teams is not exactly unheard of, judging by the sheer number of travel teams active in the county. |
|
kate of Powhatan
Mar. 30, 2010, 10:57 AM
As an educator in the public school sector, I can tell you that in many cases, sports are what keeps our children in school. Many do not have a supportive home life and coaches and teams acts as their motivators for coming to and succeeding in school. Sports not only teach valuable life lessons they encourage students to succeed. Many sports teams earn their own money through ticket sales and fund raising. YES, general education is VERY important, but if we cannot motivate students to attend and excel in school then will smaller class sizes make a difference? my thoughts
Mar. 22, 2010, 01:45 PM
I am sure that teamwork, respect and responsibility can and should be learned in many places at home for one.And from what I can see from many students it is sadly lacking.As for the athletes having to keep a higher grade point average as an incentive to play. We all know that does not happen. Sports have some how become all important. It is not. Sports should be secondary. But somehow society has made it seem like the end all. How sad that sports has come to take presidents over education. what of Powhatan
Feb. 26, 2010, 02:00 PM
Sports are extremely important. They help teach teamwork, respect and responsiblity - not to mention the athletes have to keep a higher grade point average as an incentive to play. Sports also generate a good deal of revenue. Have you not been to a home football game? New Powhatan Mom
Feb. 15, 2010, 06:19 PM
What about having bus stops in neighborhoods instead of picking up and dropping off each child at thier house? This is bound to save the school money and likely cut the length of bus rides down for some of the kids too. I agree with you completely that sports should be cut before academics, but that is an unpopular, and therefore unlikely, decision for the school board. qhgirl of reality
Feb. 15, 2010, 11:03 AM
How about cutting the transportation budget? I understand that about 1/3 of the cost of educating a child goes into the transportation (maintenance, salary of drivers equipment etc..) Why not offer parents a choice.. either drive your kid to school.. OR.. pay for the transportation service. Only the very poorest families would be provided subsidised transportation. Let’s spend money enriching the educational experience (that means education AND sports and other activities like chorus, art etc).. not driving the kids around! I imagine that there would be a need for fewer vehicles.. and probably longer routes, but at least we would be liable to get better education for the kids. Paladin of Have Gun, Will Travel
Feb. 11, 2010, 07:17 PM
I don’t disagree with you, but sports are one of the great sacred cows of high school, and there’s no way the school system will cut back on them. The schools would not have the courage to withstand the backlash from parents. Submit Your Comments Below |